
Review | The Stage | Candide | Welsh National Opera 2025
"Amy J Payne's stage savvy, joyous Old Lady – the latter a demonstration of how to maximise every opportunity in both text and score to brilliant comic effect"
Review | Midlands Music Reviews | Candide | Welsh National Opera 2025
"above all, the panache displayed by Amy J Payne’s Old Lady is extraordinary."
Review | Edinburgh Music Review | The Merry Widow | Scottish Opera 2025
"Russian mafioso Kromov and his wife Olga (bass-baritone Matthew Siveter in his Scottish Opera debut and multi-talented English mezzo Amy J Payne) delivered a strong deadpan comedic performance (with great Russian accents) but the highlight was their Russian dance… at the beginning of Act II, accompanied by the chorus in harmony – prompting a hugely merited ovation from the audience."
"Russian mafioso Kromov and his wife Olga (bass-baritone Matthew Siveter in his Scottish Opera debut and multi-talented English mezzo Amy J Payne) delivered a strong deadpan comedic performance (with great Russian accents) but the highlight was their Russian dance… at the beginning of Act II, accompanied by the chorus in harmony – prompting a hugely merited ovation from the audience."
Review | Plays To See | The Rake's Progress | English Touring Opera 2024
"Amy J Payne made the most of Mother Goose’s all-too-brief appearances and a costume that contained surprises worthy of Bunuel or Dali."
Review | Music OMH | The Yeoman of the Guard | Opera Holland Park 2024
"With her rich mezzo-soprano, Amy J Payne is a suitably haughty Dame Carruthers….[her] interpretation is perfectly pitched."
Review | The Times | The Yeoman of the Guard | Opera Holland Park 2024
"There are particularly memorable performances from Amy J Payne as a formidable Dame Carruthers…"
Review | Opera Now | L'incoronazione di Poppea | English Touring Opera 2023
"the dramatic star is Amy J Payne as the nurse Arnalta, showing just how to bring character and depth to singing without moving a muscle, as with her beguiling lullaby as Poppea sleeps."
Review | Opera Now | L'incoronazione di Poppea | English Touring Opera 2023
"…one of several artists who from their first notes made the listener sit bolt upright [was] the mezzo-soprano Amy J Payne, known to many as one of the best comprimarios on the circuit, here given a role commensurate with her talents as Arnalta"
